The island of Nantucket, Mass., has lengthy been Tom Forman and Tanya McQueen Forman’s favourite place. Mr. Forman, 50, a tv producer, grew up outdoors Boston and spent summers on Nantucket along with his household. When he launched the island to Ms. McQueen Forman, who’s initially from Texas, she was smitten, too.
“We introduced our household out each single summer season since I met Tom, and we’ve been collectively for 18 years,” mentioned Ms. McQueen Forman, 51, an inside designer and former TV persona on residence enchancment exhibits like “Excessive Makeover: Dwelling Version,” the place she met Mr. Forman. “It was simply our dream place.”
When the pandemic struck, they had been dwelling in Los Angeles with their two youngest youngsters, Owen, now 20, and Bee, 18. (Their two older youngsters had already moved out.) And so they frightened they’d have to interrupt the Nantucket custom, as a result of journey had grow to be so sophisticated.
Nonetheless, they managed to make the cross-country journey. As soon as they received to the island, they realized there was little purpose to go away anytime quickly. “We found that Tom may work from anyplace,” Ms. McQueen Forman mentioned. “We got here for our normal three-week journey and thought, ‘Why would we return to L.A.?’”
They discovered a longer-term rental to remain for just a few extra months, however had no rapid plans to purchase a home. “We all the time dreamed of sometime proudly owning our own residence right here, however thought we must wait till I retired,” Mr. Forman mentioned.
However as serial renovators, they couldn’t assist following the true property listings. One morning, perusing the listings on separate units, they concurrently found a brand new one — for a Nineteenth-century dairy barn that had been dismantled in New Jersey, transported to Nantucket and rebuilt as a 4,000-square-foot home within the Nineties.
“We had been inside earshot of each other, and I mentioned, ‘I do know we’re not shopping for a home proper now, however there’s one on the market that we have now to go take a look at,’” Ms. McQueen Forman mentioned. Mr. Forman was about to recommend the identical factor.
Once they received there, “We simply checked out each other and fell for it,” she mentioned.
They purchased the property for $3.295 million in October 2020. Whereas they admired the previous barn’s uncovered posts and beams, there have been issues they needed to alter, starting with the additions of the final three a long time.
“There was a lot to work with, however there was a lot mistaken, too,” Ms. McQueen Forman mentioned. “I used to be decided to honor the coastal vibe and the historical past, however to make it very cool and hip, mixing trendy touches with the previous.”
Step one could be overhauling all 5 ’90s-era loos. As development started, it shortly turned clear that these updates wouldn’t occur as shortly as they do on TV. It took roughly a 12 months to finish the loos.
“When you concentrate on the truth that I met Tom on a present the place we constructed a home in a single week, doing 5 loos that took a 12 months simply stumped me,” Ms. McQueen Forman mentioned. “It was arduous for me to just accept.”
However after plying their contractors with doughnuts and low within the morning and beer on the finish of the day, they received it achieved, together with his-and-hers loos off the first bed room. Ms. McQueen Forman received a rest room with a free-standing, cast-iron soaking tub and floral wallpaper; Mr. Forman received beadboard paneled partitions and a tadelakt bathe with an arched doorway.
Renovating the kitchen took one other 12 months. Ms. McQueen Forman tucked new cupboards and home equipment behind paneled partitions that cease in need of the ceiling. Aiming for a country vibe, she topped stable white-oak cupboards with soapstone counters and left the wooden and stone unsealed. On the opposite facet of one of many paneled partitions, dealing with the lounge, she added doorways that open to a hid pantry and a full-height beverage fridge that makes it straightforward to fill coolers for the seaside.
Upstairs, the place there was a sleeping loft overlooking the lounge, she enclosed the area with divided-light home windows to create a house workplace for Mr. Forman.
After determining the right way to conceal electrical wiring, plumbing traces and air-conditioning ducts across the constructing’s open construction, they added ornamental touches: a large-scale knotted rope paintings by Alex Buchanan mounted above the fireside; a wooden eating room chandelier from the Spherical Prime Antiques Present, in Texas; and a classic rattan bar that Mr. Forman had shipped from Indianapolis.
With Bee leaving for faculty later this 12 months, the couple plan to separate their time between Los Angeles and Nantucket. To date, they’ve spent near $1 million on the renovation, Mr. Forman estimated, however they proceed to make updates.
“It’s been a painstaking, nonhistoric restoration,” Mr. Forman mentioned. “It’s not a well-known constructing or an essential constructing. It’s only a cool constructing.”
For weekly e-mail updates on residential actual property information, enroll right here.